The Crown Has Not Fallen: How Much Grace Does Miss SA Need?

The Crown Has Not Fallen: How Much Grace Does Miss SA Need?

The 14th of November 2026 saw Gauteng-born Tiyani Makamu crowned as the new Miss South Africa at the tail end of a ceremony with fierce competition between twelve belles of Mzansi vying for glory and the chance to make a difference with the coveted title. However, from the show’s temporary substitute crown to questionable production values, SA’s premium beauty pageant was not without its fair share of polarised public opinion stemming from teething problems arising from the show’s transition of ownership and the departure of Stephanie Weil in July 2025 after serving as CEO for six years.

The questions have been leaning more on the negative side of things. Has Miss SA fallen off? Should there have been better judges? What happened to the iconic Mowana crown?

Tiyani Makamu crowned Miss SA 2026 | Credit: Miss South Africa

The better question, however, would be: how much grace should the organisation be afforded in order to find its proper stride under new leadership? The question might seem like an unjustifiable request. Of course, this is Miss South Africa, an exemplary exhibition of beauty and women’s empowerment that has pedastalled the likes of Zozibini Tunzi, Shudufhadzo Musida and Demi-Leigh Tebow, among others. With that said, the impact of a sudden change of leadership should not be undermined, especially when the dust hasn’t even had a few years to settle.

Among other talking points such as fan favourite Makhosazana Masango’s disappointing showing and netizens criticising the show’s increasingly progressive leaning, the winner’s crown bore the brunt of mob justice, particularly on Facebook and on X, where disgruntled watchers likened it to the kiddies Burger King paper crown. Indeed, even the words “burger king crown miss sa” show up as a Google suggestion now. I was also taken aback by the crown when I first saw it.

I can imagine that a lot of passionate followers of the pageant were confused to learn through Nungu Diamonds’ statement, the official crown partner of Miss SA, that the replacement crown was in fact not their own creation. According to their statement, the company supplied the ceremony with the crown as a gesture of “goodwill”, since an agreement on the usage of the Mowana crown had not been reached. For some unknown reason, the organisation choose to not take up the favour, and they said nothing of this in their official statement as well a day after the ceremony. However, the statements of Miss SA and Nungu Diamonds overlapped in one aspect: the crown of 2026 was a stopgap.

The classic Mowana crown | Credit: Miss South Africa

So, there’s still hope. The Mowana crown just might make a return on the show’s next iteration next year should ongoing negotiations between the organisation and the bespoke jewellers reach favourable terms. But that is something that will need time.

Perhaps the crown on the organisation’s own head hasn’t fallen. The crowning of Tiyani Makamu is a testament to this—they certainly got the scoring right on their rubric when checking for beauty that can compete internationally, intellect sharp enough to foster change and make an impact, and capacity to use the organisation to broker societal progress and to inspire. They also came out and encouraged dialogue between themselves and South Africans while also accepting critiques. A good thing. The organisation simply needs to sort out its own head first, and I am optimistic that the best is yet to come in future instalments and that there will be a united consensus on the quality of the show, as has always been the case.

Post a Comment

#FOLLOW US ON INSTAGRAM